Tomas – James Palumbo

Tomas - James PalumboI finished Tomas 2 days ago and I’m still digesting what I think. I spotted the book advertised on a billboard on London Bridge station and it immediately stood out.

The book’s cover was striking, simple and the poster came with some quotes that made it sound intriguing. Stephen Fry gave it a recommendation, plus I recognised James Palumbo’s name as the man behind the Ministry Of Sound – the centre of clubbing culture in the 90s.

So what’s Tomas about? Well, it’s basically a sharp satire of the rampant consumerism of the early 21st century: highly-paid professional footballers; money-grabbing merchant bankers; desire for plastic surgery; celebrity culture – many of the things that are currently being blamed for the onset of the recession.

Palumbo serves up surreal images and a kind of black comedy that is at turns extraordinarily funny, but also very difficult to read. Tomas is actually quite disturbing and shocking and the humour isn’t often strong enough to save it from becoming simply gruesome.

Many of Palumbo’s images and characters are cleverly drawn – representing Russia as a Great Bear is hardly new, but it works here – but the increasingly bizarre nature of the plot as the novel continues means that the characters become secondary.

By the time the book drew to a close, I was thoroughly confused and had less and less idea what was going on. The twist at the end simply served to baffle me even more.

On the plus side, Palumbo’s writing style is sharp and incisive at times and he has a turn of phrase is, at times, delightful. It will also be interesting to see how accurate a satire Tomas really is once history has its say on the first recession of the 21st century.

But overall, my feeling was that Tomas is a novel that is far too much like the flashy, insubstantial culture it sets out to debunk. Too much artifice and not enough delivery.


2 Responses to “Tomas – James Palumbo”

  1. linusbey Says:

    I agree with you completely. I too have seen the ads to this book in the Tube and was encouraged by Stephen Fry and Noel Fielding’s endorsements. While I wasn’t expecting this century’s Evelyn Waugh at any rate, I thought an educated man well-versed in the superficial world of the tabloids and seemingly disillusioned by his milieu could at the very least produce an interesting satire. But I think this book fails to deliver and is grossly overrated. It is the ramblings of an angsty teenage punk rocker with some imagination. Comparing Palumbo to Rabelais or Carroll or Voltaire would be desecrating literature.

  2. Phoebe Wonder (@PhoebeWonder) Says:

    For a first novel, this aint half bad and I have to say it had me hooked. At times it really is hilarious, but I would recommend that if you choose to buy it, make sure you read it with an open mind. There has been a lot of hype about the book – hence why I bought it – but I would say you should take it for what it is – a satire about society – because if you take it too seriously, you may just miss the point. As I said as a first novel this isn’t bad, I am looking forward to the second one – “Tancredi “

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: